Review: Manitou Minute Super 140mm with 20mm Thru Axle

November 18, 2009 10:19 am

Some time ago, I go in the Manitou Minute Super 140 to review on MTB198. This lightweight 140mm travel mountain bike suspension fork with a 20mm thru axle is one of the many 140mm travel forks on the market today. With the drastic increase in 140mm travel full suspension mountain bikes on the market, every suspension fork manufacturer has a thru axle and quick release version of a 140mm travel fork in their lineup and this is the offering from Manitou (now owned by Hayes). For compete specs and more pictures of the Manitou Minute Super 140 review fork, hit up this initial, first-look post.

The Manitou Minute 140 Install and Setup

Manitou 20mm Thru Axle

The Manitou Minute installs just like any other suspension fork, so getting it on the bike and ready to roll was a relatively easy process. My only real complaint during install was the enormous process you have to go through to get the front wheel on the bike. This review fork from Manitou came spec’ed with their 20mm thru axle. I find that a thru axle is necessary on 140mm travel mountain bikes to increase front end stiffness, but the install of the 20mm TA on the Manitou is one of the most complicated setups on the market. Not only are there 5 bolts you have to loosen and tighten down, but there are no catches for the axle in the fork lowers. You have to hold the bike at the right height to get the axle through the front hub. This makes getting the front wheel on your bike a real pain…especially with all of the QR TA’s on the market.

Initial setup on the Manitou Minute was pretty straight forward and easy. There is one air valve to control the air spring, the opposite leg controls the lockout and at the bottom of the fork let you will find the rebound adjustment. After a couple of runs back and forth on a small rocky section of trail, I had the fork dialed where I needed it and was ready to roll on. I did find that the rebound adjustment on the Minute was really sensitive. By turning it even just a little bit clockwise, it really slowed down the action of the fork. I ended up leaving it almost all the way wide open.

On the Trail with the Manitou Minute 140

Turner 5.Spot

Turner 5.Spot

Over the course of this several month review process, I took this fork to a multitude of different riding conditions to see how it could handle everything from smooth to super tech. The 140mm travel suspension fork has to be able to handle a lot of different terrain as the riders on 5.5″ trail bikes are the most diverse crowd in mountain biking.

Damping and Suspension Action

The suspension action on the Manitou Minute Super 140 was ok. As long as the trail stayed smooth, the fork kept pace and the easy to use platform/lockout mechanism did a great job of locking out the fork for extended, smooth climbing sections. When things started to get really rough and technical, the fork seemed to lose its composure some. I could feel the suspension changing directions through the stroke which tells me that the damping action needs some work. The transition between positive and negative movement is not a smooth as it needs to be. As mentioned before, the rebound setting was very sensitive to changes, so some of this feeling could not be taken out of the fork without really slowing down the rebound to the point it was packing up under multiple hits.

Small bump sensitivity and travel quality stayed pretty consistent when the trail was pretty smooth though…which makes me think that the suspension setup on this fork is more geared towards smoother cross country styled riding.

Stiffness and Trail Behavior

Again, if the trail stayed smooth…the fork behaved. But when things got rough…even the 20mm TA on the Manitou Minute could make up for the lightweight crown and brace. I could feel the flex in this fork through rock gardens and landing small drops. At 3.65 lbs. with axle, this is almost expected in a way. You can not get lightweight, stiff and affordable all in the same sentence so something had to give. With the Manitou Minute, they gave up overall fork stiffness in favor of having a lightweight overall package.

Overall Thoughts on the Manitou Minute Super 140

After riding this fork for several months, I really think it is geared toward the cross country end of the 140mm trail bike spectrum. For that reason, most of the potential purchasers are going to be more attracted to the even lighter QR version of the Minute. The fork seemed to work ok as long as I didn’t start really pushing the limits of a 140mm setup. In cross country, smooth riding conditions, everything seemed to work as planned but as soon as it got rough…things started to go downhill with suspension action and overall stiffness.

The Manitou Minute is a good, lightweight fork option for the rider that wants a 140mm bike but probably isn’t going to use it to the full potential. If you are really focused on overall weight and mainly ride more groomed sections of trail, the Manitou Minute will probably work within your weight requirements and budget. For those of you that ride more technical terrain, you are going to miss the stiffness and damping of the other forks in this market.

What I Liked About The Manitou Minute

  • Lightweight for a 140mm suspension fork (claimed 3.65 lbs. w/axle)
  • Overall good looks on the bike
  • Easy to use and adjust lockout mechanism (Absolute Platform)

What I Didn’t Like About the Manitou Minute

  • 20mm TA Removal and Install Way Too Complicated
  • Inconsistent Damping
  • Not as Stiff as the Competition
  • Sensitive Rebound Settings
  • No Compression Settings Independent of Lockout

Overall, I think the Manitou Minute Super 140 needs some work. What I am hoping is that Hayes does for Manitou what SRAM did for RockShox by building back up the brand with a new life and new technologies. So far…I have heard fantastic things out of the new Manitou Dorado DH fork, so – hopefully – they start to reverse engineer the technologies found in that fork down to their cross country lines. If I was a betting man…I would bet that is the route they are taking and we will probably see some significant changes to the Manitou lineup of suspension forks in the coming years.

Buy A Manitou Minute Super


MANITOU MINUTE SUPER SUSPENSION FORK ’09

MANITOU MINUTE 29 SUPER SUSP FORK ’09

Do you want to become a faster and better rider?

Becoming faster on the mountain bike trail requires some sort of program or focus. Luckily for us, James Wilson (pro MTB trainer) put together the The Ultimate MTB Workout that will get you over that speed hump and make you a faster mountain biker. This affordable and extremely comprehensive program is exactly what you are looking for to bring the speed out of your legs and against the dirt whether you are a recreational rider or racer. Click here to check out The Ultimate MTB Workout Program.

If you are looking to increase your riding skills, Ramped Riding is a 135 page eBook packed with over 15 years worth of mountain biking experience that will make you a better rider instantly, guaranteed. Click Here To Check Out Ramped Riding

Did you know?

By clicking on our links then shopping at JensonUSA, Hunk N Roll, Chainlove, and Amazon, you are helping Bike198. We use them and LBS's for our gear. Thank you for supporting the crew at Bike198.

View Comments

  • Manitou's forks lineup is way behind the competition and has been since they went overboard with OnePointFive years ago. The Sherman was a great idea, but the internals sucked. Likewise, every other Manitou fork I've ridden since has either blown up within weeks (2005 Manitou Nixon) or I've had to suffer through a noodly experience just hoping the fork didn't break on me.

  • I'd have to agree. But – like I said – I hope they can pull it through with what they have going on with their DH lineup. What surprised me is that Guitar Ted over at twentynineinches said the Manitou was stiffer than the RockShox Reba…and that is not true at all (I have both).

  • Hayes has a revised Absolute damper out that improves the overall performance of the platform. Request one from their excellent customer service department (email response in less than 24 hours; new damper on my doorstep in a week) and give it a go.

    And “enormous process” to get the front wheel on?!!? Are you serious?? Do we so easily forget the Marzocchi QR20 design? Or even their standard 20mm TA (they should have included a rubber mallet with the '05 66!)? I've been on 20mm forks exclusively for more than five years, and Manitou's HexLoc is no more difficult than an other design I've used (Marz, RS and WhiteBros; never owned a Fox). For goodness sake just flip the bike over and hold the wheel – not the bike – to line up the hub in the drops. Slide the axle in, tighten end cap and pinch bolts and you're good to go. I did this for YEARS with my old Sherman, each time I rode, since I had a Fork-Up'ed Yakima roof rack. Slightly inconvenient? Yes. An “enormous process”? Hardly.

    I've pounded the crud out of my Minute Super (breaking a Norco 4By frame in the process) and, though not as stiff as, say, a Pike, it weighs in at nearly 2# less. For the weight I find it exceptionally solid. Indeed, surprisingly so. I wouldn't ride around 50/50'ing doubles or chucking it off anything larger than ~5ft, but for the type of terrain generally encountered on most AM trails it's fine (for my ride weight of ~160, at least).

    I also find the suspension action smooth and generally well behaved. The only issue of note is that the initial stroke is SO plush that, IMHO, it tends to afflict the fork with an excessive degree of brake dive. The end stroke ramps aggressively to ward off bottoming while descending aggressive terrain, but given the forks plushness it would be nice if a real speed-sensitive low speed compression circuit adjustment were available (the ABS platform is much too coarse to use as a true low speed comp tweak).

    And as a side note, I've had nothing but prompt and courteous customer service from the Hayes Group. From a real live person. How refreshing to use the “Contact Us” link on a website and actually get a timely response!

    Is the Minute perfect? No. Is it generally up to their competition? IMHO yes. People seem to set RS on a golden pedestal these days, quick to overlook things like constant problems with their DualAir design, and apparently their inability to put out a fork with an external Floodgate adjustment that doesn't weep oil after a short time (I've had THREE RS's do this, so it's NOT an isolated thing). The '09 Boxxer was a bit of a mess, as well. And Marz? You'll have to pry my '05 888 out of my hands, since most of what they've produced since moving mfg'ing out of Italy has been poop. …Though the Italians did seem to think oil was optional some days. ;-)

    Anyhow, thanks for the great site. Cheers.

  • Thanks for you input!

    The 20mm TA is an enormous process in comparison with the other thru axles on the market today. Like you…I have been on the 20mm TA bandwagon for awhile now…if this was 3 or 4 years ago, that would not have been an issue. But…in comparison with the competition in today's market, it is a huge limiting factor.

    I have had great CS out of the Hayes group as well and we finished up reviewing the Stroker Ace brakes that we loved and I am in the process of throwing the Grams through the ringer now. Like I said in the review, I see promising things coming out of Hayes right now so I hope they can continue that path and update the Minute to better compete with the other 140mm forks on the market today.

  • Thanks for you input!

    The 20mm TA is an enormous process in comparison with the other thru axles on the market today. Like you…I have been on the 20mm TA bandwagon for awhile now…if this was 3 or 4 years ago, that would not have been an issue. But…in comparison with the competition in today's market, it is a huge limiting factor.

    I have had great CS out of the Hayes group as well and we finished up reviewing the Stroker Ace brakes that we loved and I am in the process of throwing the Grams through the ringer now. Like I said in the review, I see promising things coming out of Hayes right now so I hope they can continue that path and update the Minute to better compete with the other 140mm forks on the market today.

  • I am looking to replace the Manitou Minute One on my Stumpjumper Pro 120. I had been looking at Fox and Rock Shox. There is an exchange program available through Manitou that now has me giving thought to another Manitou. If not for this exchange program that offers some value I would not be considering Manitou because the Minute One that came on the bike has been less than satisfactory. Poor quality components. Rebound adjust made of cheap plastic broke early on later the travel adjust broke. Purchase by Hayes Group gives me a little more confidence but the reviews are not glowing. Any thoughts anyone?

    • I think the Hayes group is going to bring the Manitou name back to their former glory, but it is going to take some time to move through the pipeline. The Dorado is getting fantastic reviews, so that is a sign they are going in the right direction. In the meantime, the offerings from Fox and RockShox are better.

Leave a Reply


Trackbacks

    blog comments powered by Disqus

    Sponsors

    Write for Bike198

    Want to contribute content to mountain.bike198.com? Gain access to thousands of mountain bikers and be a part of a growing community by submitting guest tips and reviews on Bike198. Hit up the contact form to get started!

    Write for 198

    Video Category

    GoPro HD on Road Bike